Living Mulches systems consist of establishing a perennial legume understory grown as a living ground cover under an arable crop and kept in the field for multiple years, without the need for re-seeding. Cash crops are directly drilled into the understory each year. It offers an opportunity for organic and low-input systems. Rather than fertility building leys taking up part of the rotation, the legume living mulch is thought to build fertility simultaneously with crop production. This approach has the potential to increase whole-farm productivity, especially as it can be a way to reduce use of inputs and tillage. It can be used as a way to provide an extra year of crop production in the rotation.
Despite this potential there are also practical challenges. ORC’s previous research found that the establishment of the legume and the competitiveness between the mulch and the cash crop results in lower annual yields.
Hannah and Alex Fraser, at Denby Hall Farm, aimed to address some of these challenges by screening different legume species, varieties and mixtures as well as establishment techniques, with the objective to maximise environmental benefits while reducing costs associated with yield penalty. The Living Mulch Farming System experiment included 6 treatments, involving different white clover varieties, and combinations of white clover and other species (Persian clover, black medic and bird’s-foot trefoil) with winter wheat (Maris Widgeon) as the cash crop. The results presented here focus on the first year of the living mulch.
You can read more about our trial results in our factsheets:
The timing of establishment and the choice of equipment kit are key to the overall success of a living mulch system. In our trial, the high weed burden during the establishment year was likely due to the summer establishment of the mulch, combined with reduced tillage practices. Slightly higher weed pressure was observed in the control strip, suggesting that the presence of the mulch may help suppress weed growth. Single-species white clover variety AberAce had the most consistently high results.
This context affected the crop performance. Early weed pressure and mulch-crop competition for light, nutrients and water contributed to lower yields in the first year, with reductions of up to 70% compared with a ‘control’ comparison strip at the edge of the field (normal tillage intensity, no mulch).

Alex Fraser gives his view on the second year of the process:
“Our experience for the second year was really positive, the mulch was well established throughout the field and as it was so dry it didn’t compete with the arable crop and stayed out of the way until harvest allowing combining to happen with ease. We even managed to bale the straw.
The oats did well, and were a lot more competitive than the wheat, which I put down to their different growth habit but also the Claydon drilling system which worked very well. Yield was about 1t/ac but this field hasn’t been down to grass for about 6 years so has a very low residual fertility now and with the dry weather I think this probably wasn’t too bad!”
A key finding was that mixtures of mulch species did not perform significantly better than single-species mulches in weed management or regarding the competition with the cash crops, thus potentially simplifying management decisions around mulch establishment. But we found that mixtures had higher positive biodiversity scores, and we found early improvements in soil organic matter, earthworm abundance and soil structure for some mulch species.
Alex says “I don’t think there was much difference between varieties in the living mulch strips in Year Two either, but from the few plants I saw of Lotus Corniculatus, these would be problematic at a high inclusion. I think sticking to the small white clovers and black medic (Medicago Lupulina) would be a good option.”
We found some early indications of better soil health for some of the living mulch species. The soil structure was generally better in the strips containing living mulches and there were higher earthworm numbers in the white clover single-species strips.
We also used the Sandy Tool from Trinity Agtech to model the public good benefits of the living mulch system. The results indicated lower emissions intensities in living mulch stips than the control and headlands, almost half in some cases! It was primarily due to higher estimation of C sequestration rather than differences in fuel usage or residue management. Mulch treatment strips had also the lowest modelled N leaching rates compared to the headlands. Biodiversity results showed the potential for living mulches to encourage greater pollinator numbers. With mixtures achieving highest overall positive biodiversity scores compared with single-species treatments.
We highly recommend that future work prioritises multi‑year replicated trials, more thorough investigation into the associated below‑ground processes, and a clearer understanding of how species choice and management can balance competition with the crop while maximising soil health and environmental and nutritional advantages.
The Organic Research Centre is currently working on a new ADOPT project, screening new potential mulch species including herbs and different sowing systems.
