Roadmap to a greener farming future

ORC welcomes Defra’s roadmap for a transition to deliver a better, fairer farming system in England. We strongly support the participatory approach and are involved in three of Defra’s Environmental Land Management ‘Test and Trials’.

ORC’s Head of Research Dr Will Simonson however, calls for the lack of specific inclusion of organic farming in the future schemes to be addressed.

Defra’s path to sustainable farming

In the New Year the UK will begin a seven year transition period away from EU-based farm payment rules towards a system that will reward farmers for maintaining and restoring the natural environment, ensuring livestock health and welfare, and reducing carbon emissions. This represents a potentially major contribution towards the UK targets to protect 30% of land by 2030 and reach net zero by 2050, whilst also helping to meet global goals on climate, biodiversity and landscape restoration.

On 30 November Defra published a roadmap for this post-Brexit journey. This emphasises their ambition to co-design the new policies with farmers and other agricultural stakeholders, through ongoing and new tests and trials involving around 3,000 farmers, and a three-year National Pilot involving 5,500 farmers and land managers to be rolled out from late 2021.

A welcome participatory approach

The Organic Research Centre strongly supports this participatory approach to the design of the Environmental Land Management (ELM) scheme. This principle is at the core of our own research and ongoing development of organic techniques:

  • Listening to farmers,
  • Cooperating with them on field experiments and trials,
  • Investigating market options,
  • discussing the implications of the results with the wider farming and food business communities.

The interruption of COVID-19 has not dimmed our vision for this vital partnership working, just made us – like everyone else – more creative in the tools and methods used.

Working with a number of partners, including the Soil Association, Woodland Trust and University of Reading, we are involved in three of Defra’s Tests and Trials:

  1. One aims to identify the essential building blocks for agroforestry options under ELM. (If anyone wishes to follow or be involved in the newly launched agroforestry test led by ORC, please register your interest here.)
  2. Another is exploring the use of videos and podcasts in sharing knowledge and advice via our experience managing Agricology.
  3. The third explores the role of certification and barriers and enablers to the uptake of practices linked to public goods delivery on farm, incorporating a streamlined version of our Public Goods Tool.

We call for more investment in organic and agroecological R&D

Defra’s roadmap also targets more investment in long-term research and development. This is essential to inform the effective delivery of schemes across ELM’s three tiers, from on-farm improvement of soil health, water quality, woodlands and hedgerows, biodiversity and pest management (Tier 1) to actions that put back nature and wildness back into the local countryside (Tier 2) and wider landscapes (Tier 3).

Given the focus of ELM on public goods, this is an opportunity to address the historically negligible levels of R&D funding in organic and agroecological techniques. With its 3,000 farmers managing 300,000 ha of land across England, the organic sector has been an important testing ground for practices that have even wider relevance and applicability under the new farming payment regime.

“The focus on public goods is an opportunity to address historically negligible levels of R&D funding in organic and agroecological techniques.”


Catalysing this knowledge transfer is a key priority, but in the opposite direction. So too is supporting existing and new organic-certified farmers through new R&D and, vitally, developing specific provisions within the ELM and complementary schemes (e.g. the Animal Health and Welfare pathway) themselves.

There is a notable lack of specific inclusion of organic farming in the future ELM and related schemes. We call on this to be addressed so that the increasingly valued public goods and benefits already being delivered by organic producers are not put at risk.

See also: One year in, one year to go: Assessing Public Good delivery on farm

Sign up to our e-Bulletin

Sign up to ORC’s e-bulletin and be the first to receive updates from our in-the-field research and the latest organic and agroecological news and events. Delivered to your inbox monthly.

Newsletter signup

By submitting this form, you are agreeing for us to contact you by email about our research, knowledge exchange, policy support and fundraising. Your details will only be used by the Organic Research Centre (ORC) in adherence with our Privacy Policy.

If you would like to change how you receive communications from the ORC or update your contact details, please click the appropriate link at the footer of any email you receive from us, or contact: